| Location | Assigned Companies | Year closed | Current use |
| 106 Collingwood Ave. | Engine 23, Precinct 16 Complex | 2010 | Vacant |
| 2025 Bailey Ave. | Engine 31, Ladder 14 | 2009 | Church/Halfway House Resource Center |
| 275 Kehr St. | Engine 33, 5th Battalion Chief | 2006 | True Bethel Baptist Church Help Center |
| 1655 Elmwood Ave. | Engine 36 | 2005 | Private Residence |
| 395 Amherst St. | Ladder 12 | 2005 | Private Residence |
| 638 Fillmore Ave. | Ladder 11, 3rd Battalion Chief | 2003 | Private Owner |
| 306 Jersey St. | Engine 2, Ladder 9, Squad 11 | 1999 | Private Owner - Ted Constantine |
| 707 Washington St. | Engine 4, Engine 9, Ladder 1, Squad 9, 2nd Battalion | 1994 | Printing Company (Leader All Surface Printing) |
| 1420 Main St. | Engine 16 | 1991 | Offices:My Fellowship World/Veterans Housing |
| 131 Southside Pkwy. | Engine 30, Ladder 10, Quad 6 | 1981 | Apartments |
| 176 Chicago St. | Engine 8, Ladder 8 | 1978 | Private Owner |
| 64 Amherst St. | Engine 15, Squad 7 | 1976 | Private Residence |
| 1197 Niagara St. | Engine 11, Ladder 4 | 1966 | Rich's Outlet Bakery |
| 166 Cleveland Ave. | Engine 37, Chemical 5 | 1966 | Private Residence |
| 17 Whitfield St. | Engine 30, Precinct 15 Complex | 1960 | Apartments |